The ecologist majority's strategy to reduce the presence of advertising in public spaces has just taken a serious hit. In a decision made on July 7, the administrative court annulled several provisions of the local advertising regulations (RLP), deeming that they excessively infringed upon economic freedoms and freedom of expression, without sufficient justification in terms of protecting the living environment. This decision follows an appeal lodged by three professional unions and several companies specialized in advertising displays.
Big billboards might make a comeback
Among the measures that were annulled is the ban on the famous "4x3" billboards visible along the ring road and major Lyon routes. The regulation adopted in 2023 limited their size to 2 or 4 m², while the Environmental Code allows for formats of 12 m². For the judges, such a reduction compromises the readability of advertisements and vbeyond what is necessary to preserve the landscape.
The same observation applies to signs installed on rooftops and terraces. In recent years, several iconic illuminated signs have been removed, especially along the banks of the Rhône. Once again, the court believes that a total ban is disproportionate and that more flexible rules regarding their size or integration could have sufficed.
Some rules are still in effect
Not everything is being challenged, though. The judges have also annulled the ban on advertisements installed on construction site tarps. However, they confirmed an important provision of the regulation: the obligation to turn off illuminated advertisements at night in certain areas of the Lyon Metropolis.
This decision could shake up the advertising landscape in Lyon. Now, it remains to be seen whether the Metropolis will choose to take action.
the need to review its regulations in order to balance urban landscape protection with respect for economic freedoms.